As of the February 6 close the S&P 500 was about 6% higher for the year to date in terms of price appreciation. The Dow Jones Industrial Average was ahead by 6.7% for the same time period. Interestingly, both averages are very close to their all-time high water marks. And both are flirting with big round numbers; the S&P 500 oscillates around the 1,500 mark while the Dow plays footsie with 14,000. It may sound silly, but historical patterns show that these big round numbers actually can be formidable support or resistance levels. Call it irrational investor psychology – but that’s what the numbers say. So at this juncture a few questions are in order. Does this rally have the legs to carry us into macro growth market territory? What are the risks that could keep things lurching along around these resistance levels for awhile? Could things get really bad again – are investors too blithely complacent about potential X-factors that could send things heading sharply south?
Those all-time high water marks (14,164 for the Dow, 1,565 for the S&P 500) are fueling lots of chatter about the so-called “Great Rotation” – a structural shift from fixed income into equities. One could ask, is the Great Rotation any more real than the Great Pumpkin of “Peanuts” fame? Perhaps. Or perhaps not. The bulls point to the $11.3 billion net inflows that came tumbling into US equity funds in the first two weeks of 2013. That’s the biggest fortnightly inflow since April 2000. The bears say…yeah, April 2000. Remember what happened after that? Ouch.
But market conditions today are hardly like they were in that last dizzying month of the dot-com bubble. Equity valuations are much more modest – maybe not screaming bargains but not wildly overpriced either. And, lest we forget, the yield on the 10-year Treasury was over 6% in the first quarter of 2000. If anything could drive frustrated yield-seekers out of bonds and into equities, then the fact that in inflation-adjusted terms you actually have to pay to own the 10-year Treasury – surely that should be at the top of the list of reasons, no?
Great Rotation or not, we do believe that the landscape looks reasonably promising for equities in 2013. But we also don’t think it’s going to be a one-way joyride upward. The market still moves more to the utterances (or non-utterances) of Ben Bernanke or Mario Draghi on any given day than it does to factors more directly pertinent to the business value of the companies that make up the indexes. The 10-year yield is still mostly below 2%, meaning that any Great Rotation money that’s out there still has one foot planted in the bond market while it gingerly treads further into equities. And brisk rallies like the one we’ve seen since the beginning of the year – especially when contending with macro-trend resistance levels – are vulnerable to significant corrections before they finally succeed in scaling the wall. We have to be prepared for perhaps a bit more volatility than we’ve had to deal with for awhile.
This January the first exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the U.S. – now called the SPDR S&P 500 – will celebrate its 20th anniversary. Exchange-traded products (ETPs), including both exchange-traded funds and exchange-traded notes (ETNs), offer a multitude of benefits to investors including lower fees and direct exposure to a wide range of asset classes from the staple must-haves for any portfolio to the exotic realms of emerging markets currencies and buy-write option strategies. While many investors have already taken up ETFs for their portfolio we expect this trend will continue in the months and years ahead.
Exchange traded products have grown tremendously over the two decades since SPDR’s maiden voyage. There are now around 1,436 products in total, comprising $1.3 trillion in assets. This is still a far cry from the estimated $10 trillion that is invested in mutual funds. But investors are showing an increasing propensity to do what we at MVCM have been doing some time now – using ETPs are a core component of a prudently diversified asset allocation strategy.
The evidence that has accumulated over time – and to the core feature of our approach to investment management – shows that the most important decision investors can make is around strategic asset allocation, and ETPs serve a valuable role here. For one, you don’t have to worry about your fund manager straying from the stated strategy in search of better returns. Style drift, as this is called, is not helpful from an asset allocation standpoint. With ETPs you know what you are getting – large cap value equity, total return bonds or what have you. Lately, ETFs and ETNs have been launched that offer even more specific objectives such as high dividend yields, lower volatility and many alternative investment options, allowing advisors to diversify across a very broad and deep range of asset classes.
Another area where ETPs are likely to grow is in 401(k) plans. New regulations put in place earlier this year require more transparent fee disclosure to retirement plan participants, including the fees related to the plans’ investment choices. The generally lower fee structure of ETFs will likely attract more plan sponsors and managers to utilizing these vehicles in greater number going forward.
So let us all wish exchange-traded products a very happy 20th and appreciate the value they have brought to the world of investing. We expect the next two decades will be promising indeed for their continued growth.
Every day we watch what is going on in the world and are constantly given reasons to be concerned, stressed and worried about our immediate futures and beyond. As we get ready to celebrate this traditional holiday, it is a good time to remind ourselves that we do indeed have many things about which to be thankful and to focus on those. Here is a variation of these sentiments as they relate to what is going on in the economy and world markets.
In 2012 there were many reasons for markets to potentially melt into panic. The ongoing crisis in Europe, persistent economic troubles in the US, volatility in China and other developing markets, and the uncertainty around the US elections all threatened to impact the market in a severely negative way. Yet as we head into the Thanksgiving holiday the S&P 500 is up just over 10% year-to-date, and brief periods of heightened uncertainty have been tempered by long stretches of relatively low volatility growth. Of course, this does not mean that we are out of the woods, and vigilance remains the order of the day. But it is important sometimes to step back and remember that more often than not the worst case does not eventuate even when the news would sometimes suggest otherwise. Revolutions don’t happen more often than they do happen. For that we can be thankful.
The election was bitterly contested and often depressing in terms of the quality and temperament of the discourse. But as we move beyond the election into the challenges that lie ahead in the coming years, we can be thankful that we have robust mechanisms in place to keep the basic integrity of our political system intact, certainly relative to just about any other example you could imagine. Fortunately we Americans have a strong optimistic side to our character which gives us confidence that in the end we can figure out and solve our most pressing problems.
No doubt we will have more in the way of caustic commentary on events around us as the days and weeks progress. But for now, we simply want to be thankful for the things for which we can be thankful, and to wish each and every one of you a safe, healthy and happy Thanksgiving.
Now that the election is over and done with, US investors have turned their focus once again to the looming fiscal cliff and deepening recession in Europe – and their reaction has been anything but kind. At close on Wednesday, the Dow Jones Industrial average was down a whopping 313 points, once again bringing it below the 1300 mark.
Much of this negative reaction was brought on by comments by European Central Bank (ECB) President Mario Draghi, who discussed concerns about Germany, the Eurozone’s biggest economy. A 1.8%month-on-month fall in industrial production as well as a 3.3% decline in factory orders have resulted in the European Commission reducing Germany’s 2013 growth forecast by around half – it is now expected to grow 0.8% next year rather than the previous estimate of 1.7%.
Most disconcerting about these numbers, as Draghi stated, is that “Germany has so far been largely insulated from some of the difficulties elsewhere in the euro area”. However, these new reports and growth estimates suggest that the Eurozone’s largest economy is not immune to the problems that have been plaguing other member countries for quite some time now; most notably “deplorably high” unemployment , a weak economic outlook and a an ongoing three year long debt crisis.
The European Commission’s 2013 growth prediction for the rest of the Eurozone countries is not any better – a paltry 0.4% growth is expected, barely above recession territory.
But investors shouldn’t necessarily panic – this sentiment is vastly different from the lead-up to Draghi’s star turn in late July when he succeeded in gaining approval for the ECB to conduct sovereign bond-buying programs intended to reduce market volatility and borrowing costs for struggling Eurozone countries. The best advice for investors in our opinion is to stay disciplined and watch how the various economic concerns in both the US and Eurozone continue to play out. If we can get through the next couple months without a worst-case scenario playing out it could lead into opportunities for growth in 2013.
At the end of the third quarter the S&P 500 was perched at 16.44% year to date, a stark contrast to where we were at the same time last year at -8.68%. Driving this rally, as we have noted in a handful of these market commentaries, have been the policy measures made by central bankers around the globe. The Fed initiated a massive undertaking with so-called QE3 (or QE4ever as the financial wags put it) by pledging to buy a theoretically unlimited amount of federal debt. That followed on the heels of the aggressive measures announced earlier in the summer by ECB head Mario Draghi to “do what it takes” to shore up the Eurozone. What has ensued is what we refer to as a synthetic rally – a rally that is not being driven by fundamental economic drivers, but rather by policies meant to stimulate the economy.
So why is it important to recognize the difference between a synthetic rally and an organic growth-driven rally? In large part because of the unique nature of the unknowns. Investors, analysts and sundry financial experts alike are struggling to anticipate and make sense of what factors are really driving current market conditions during this policy driven period. With the announcement of QE3, one would have normally expected treasury yields to rise – however, yields have still not reached the already meager levels seen at the beginning of the year. This is a prime example of the lack of rhyme and reason that keeps market observers perplexed as they look for signs of transition back to organic growth and a more “normal” valuation-driven climate.
This transitional period will likely be fraught with the kind of volatility that investors have become (reluctantly) accustomed to over the past 4 years. Contributing to the turbulence will be an unhealthy admixture of political factors and wagers about the unknown, but inevitable, end of spoon-feeding by the Fed. Most immediately the passing of the 11/6 election and pending fiscal cliff loom large, but renewed inflation risk and sharply higher interest rates also lurk in the copses in the not-too-distant future.
A real growth period will announce itself by headline numbers like GDP and unemployment rates – but we may expect fleeting glimpses of the promised land via economic indicators such as consumer confidence and the various housing numbers which, as they start to rise, reflect and also encourage improvement in public sentiment. Current numbers are beginning to show some of these tantalizing glimpses, and that could turn into a high-likelihood case for 2013.
But even if that becomes our likeliest-case scenario we are mindful that the path is not paved nor the way smooth. Many variables remain to play out, starting with an election whose outcomes will very likely be dominating influences in the days and weeks after November 6.